The soaring popularity of virtual assistants has set the stage for competition. With contributions from Amazon and Google, consumers across the country have to choose between two of the tech industry’s leading brands. Neck and neck, Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant and each deliver value with their own unique selling points.
If you’ve found yourself torn between Alexa and Google Assistant, you’re not alone. The tech marketplace is increasingly complicated and difficult to navigate, full of products that are “bigger and better” and “next-gen.” To sort through the claims, you’ll need to know where Alexa and Google Assistant differ in skills and actions.
By “skills” and “actions,” we’re referencing the abilities of these products. When you assess their functionality, you’ll have a clear idea of where these virtual assistants fit within the context of your day-to-day life. Of course, your evaluation shouldn’t end there, and it’s best to begin with an overview of both systems.
Amazon Alexa
While Google Assistant has its appeal, Alexa is just as attractive to consumers searching to integrate their smart home products. Since Amazon’s first smart Echo speaker, they’ve continued to improve upon themselves and expand the functionality of their virtual assistant. Here are several categories to consider.
[1] Wake Words
Alexa has numerous wake word options, which include “Alexa,” “Amazon,” “Echo” and “Computer.” Even with this larger repertoire, Alexa is often inflexible with wording and word sequences. While it’s strong with shopping-related queries, it relies a bit too much on Wikipedia for knowledge-related queries.
[2] Abilities
In terms of basic functionality, Alexa has many of the abilities of its competitor. It allows the user to combine smart home devices into rooms, supports Routines and links to streaming sticks. At the same time, Amazon has struggled with YouTube integration due to its tensions with Google.
[3] Third-Party Skills
Amazon’s virtual assistant shines with its third-party skills, boasting an enormous number of abilities. The Echo can also receive calls from other Echos and take calls from the home phone line with the addition of an Echo Connect box. In terms of multi-user capabilities, the user has to say a command to switch accounts.
Google Assistant
The value of a virtual assistant is easy to assess in three simple categories. In looking at voice control, smart home integration and abilities, you can determine whether Google Assistant has a place in your home or if Alexa is the superior choice. Let’s start with Google Assistant’s proficiency with voice activation. Google Assistant is available as an app, and also runs on all Google Home speakers.
[1] Wake Word
Google Assistant has two “wake word” options, which are essentially the phrases which activates it. You’ll have to say, “Hey Google” or “OK Google” anytime you want to use the device. At the same time, it’s excellent at handling free-form, web-based queries and has a conversational tone with an understanding of multiple languages.
[2] Routines
Google Home connects to anything with Chromecast, though several brands like Blink, Carrier, and Haiku are still inaccessible. It allows the user to combine smart home devices into rooms for convenience and supports “Routines.” These Routines enable multiple actions in one command for quick, effortless control.
[3] Third-Party Actions
Google’s virtual assistant has a variety of third-party “actions” which let you communicate with companies like Uber or Domino’s. It can make outbound voice calls, but can’t receive them. Still, its multi-user functionality is impressive, recognizing up to six separate voices to switch seamlessly between accounts.
Comparing Alexa and Google Assistant
In terms of voice control, Google Assistant is more intelligent and flexible with wording. Alexa has more wake word options, but that’s a meager advantage that doesn’t contribute much to its overall value.
As for smart home integration, Google Assistant and Alexa are capable of the primary functions you would expect from a virtual assistant. They each enable the grouping of smart devices, as well as Routines—though, as we mentioned earlier, Amazon has had a difficult time securing YouTube integration.
Concerning functionality, Alexa has a greater breadth of abilities, numbering in the tens of thousands. Google Assistant has far fewer “actions,” which might sway a potential buyer toward Amazon. Even with their limitations, Google is catching up, though it might take them a while.
An Educated Decision
Ultimately, the right choice depends on your personal situation. If you’re searching for functionality, you might prefer Alexa, but if you’re searching for easy voice control, Google Assistant might be a better pick. You’ll also have to consider where Alexa and Google Assistant differ in skills and actions.
When deciding on your next virtual assistant for smart home control, look at more than their capacity for integration. Take a holistic approach as you weigh your options, and when you finally choose, you’ll feel confident you made an educated decision.
More About This Topic:
- More from Digitized House | Guide to the Connected Home
- Sign Up to Get Weekly Digitized House Updates
- A Closer Look at Google Assistant and Multilingual AI
- Google Assistant expands with dialect upgrades
- August Enables More Google Assistant, Amazon Alexa, IFTTT Skills
- Native Amazon Alexa Controls Debut in Bose Smart Speakers
- iDevices Bridges Apple HomeKit and Amazon Alexa Worlds
- Sonos and Amazon Alexa make beautiful music together
